Pepperdine MBA program calculates hourly worth at just $20-$30/hour

 

At least that’s how I interpreted a recent marketing email I received: 

There’s still time to participate in a 10-15 minute survey about Pepperdine University’s MBA programs, and we welcome your input.

As an incentive for participation, qualified respondents who complete the survey will be emailed a five-dollar ($5.00) Starbucks gift card within three weeks.

To participate, please click or paste this link: 
https://www.research.net/s.aspx?sm=XyMWmwo1rFBGAGd4lIDM_2bg_3d_3d

Thank you for considering participation in this survey.

More about the survey:

Pepperdine’s Business School is partnering on this survey with Eduvantis, a higher education consulting firm located in Chicago, Illinois. This survey will be administered and its data analyzed by Eduvantis. Please be assured that your identity and any information that you provide will be kept confidential. Survey results will only be analyzed in aggregate, and the information you provide will never be bought, sold, or rented. Your participation in the survey is entirely separate from, and in no way linked to, interactions you have directly with the Graziadio School of Business and Management at Pepperdine.

By contrast, a little later today I received an email from The Edinboro Castle in London (which is a pub), offering £5 for completing a survey. It took 4 minutes to complete that survey. So effectively the London pub values my time at £75 per hour. 

Does anyone else think that perhaps Pepperdine should rethink their strategy? I wonder what their response rate is. 

Simple Set-up for Promoted Tweets and get one for free?

Have you tried out Twitter Promoted Tweets? Twitter started testing Promoted Tweets over a year ago and when I investigated I immediately believed it could be a worthy option. Unfortunately I couldn’t get the budget allocated. I’m sure many other marketers have had similar experiences. But now it seems like you might just be able to give the Promoted Tweets a whirl before asking for a big chunk of budget.

Go to http://analytics.twitter.com

Step 1: Select your target audience.

Screenshot Promoted Tweets - Step 1

 

Step 2: Define what you want to promote.

Promoted Tweets - Step 2

Step 3: Select your budget.
(You need to select a Promoted Tweets daily budget and a maximum bid per engagement, plus a Promoted Accounts daily budget and maximum bid per follow.)

Promoted Tweets - Step 3

Step 4: Pay up!

promoted_tweets_step_4

Have you already tried Promoted Tweets?

If you’ve already tried Promoted Tweets please share some of your insight in comments. Include your Twitter @username so we can stay connected there too.

Let’s hope Air France does better in the AIR than on the WEB

I like Air France. I like British Airways better though to be honest. But to get to the point, Air France seems to struggle with the concept of the customer journey when it pertains to the web. Perhaps your luggage handlers can take ages at CDG to get our baggage to us, perhaps it is our cultural differences that causes to perceive many of your employees as rude and uninterested in ‘customer service’. (Oui, je sais. Service clientele n’existe pas en France!). A little while ago, I received an email from Air France announcing a contest for tickets to Colombia in the subject line.

Image

Do you see any mention of the contest in the body of the email? No.

When I clicked through from the email I still did not see any reference to the contest:

Image

So it appears that those responsible for email marketing at Air France understand nothing about building trust and creating a customer journey. This is a big fat #fail on their part.

Do you find you have less patience and can very quickly lose trust with companies that send these types of emails. Have you received any blatantly false marketing emails lately? Please share your perception/reaction in the comments section. I’d love to read about your experiences.

Update 7/18/2013, 1:31PM:

At least Air France seemed to have figure out their mistake:

airfrance3

The Power of Online and Offline Networking

Back in my younger years I had the opportunity to work with some great people at Transamerica which was then a Fortune 500. There I learned that there is great value in meeting other people – often to learn from their experiences – after all it takes a village. When I worked for Wells Fargo bank and Citibank all business bankers were encouraged to attend networking events. The experience was extraordinary. Because of this I got to ride on top of the Wells Fargo Wagon in a parade, waving at the crowd (on one of Los Angeles’ few rainy days). I was invited to attend a ribbon cutting event for the Cambodian community center in Long Beach. I assisted the Friends of the Colorado Lagoon to get a grant from Wells Fargo bank and was invited to a fund raising dinner. When I was working in investments my manager agreed to pay for me to attend Los Angeles Town Hall. There I had the privilege of meeting, shaking hands and talking to Ambassador Turki Al-Faisal of Saudi Arabia. I had the opportunity of meeting Torie Clarke the author of Lipstick on a Pig who was also once  Assistant Secretary of Defense for Public Affairs. (It’s a great book about how we live in an era of authenticity – I admire her greatly!) I had the most amazing experience being that I was studying political science, philosophy and economics – to meet the most amazing Chuck Hagel. The firmness of his handshake, the straight in the eye look, and the powerful discussion with him will be forever implanted in my mind. Chuck Hagel was a US Senior Senator and although I’m very liberal in my views if I was an American and he ran for President I would have a difficult time not voting for him even though he is Republican!

In 2006 I was asked by my employer to give a presentation to my peers in presentation training on the power and utility of networking. Ask many MBA graduates and they will tell you that the value of a network is priceless (sorry Mastercard).

I guess networking became nature or maybe more appropriately, natural to me. When I moved to Paris in 2007 I found that finding a flat was very difficult. But alas through networking with American expats I found a flat in St. Germain dés Pres and had the privilege of living in one of the most prestigious neighbourhoods in Paris. (Don’t be too jealous, my flat was the size of a Chistian Laboutin shoebox!) When I moved to the UK and considered whether I wanted to work for a company or continue being a marketing consultant my amazing business coach Suzie Sharpe advised me that in the UK, networking is paramount, especially for expats like me.

By this point I had already begun to deploy a social media marketing strategy for Oshyn. I think my good mates there will agree that this strategy raised brand awareness, and drove a massive increase in website traffic. I decided to go to meetup.com to look for events in London to attend and I luckily found Last Thursday CMS. Lucky, because I met an amazing group of people and have since met many other people through their network both online and offline.

By being active in social networks I have had the opportunity to chat with well known authors, VCs, marketing consultants and many people who specialize in the technology of my employer. I have met amazing people that I never would have otherwise met, where we have been able to talk about how to do great things or have simply become friends.

I have learned that truly we are all people. We all do “some things” the same way. We’re humans regardless of what title we hold, where we were raised, and no matter how much we have in the bank. Being able to network with people from students, to politicians, to Senior executives enables great learning opportunities and in fact many opportunities you might otherwise be oblivious.

The greatest thing I have learned in networking is in the value of learning from others. And as an added benefit, it is nice to have the ability to contact experts when you need one.

“The way of the world is meeting people through other people.” – Robbert Kerrigan

“It isn’t just what you know, and it isn’t just who you know. It’s actually who you know, who knows you, and what you do for a living.” -Bob Burg
“The richest people in the world look for and build networks, everyone else looks for work.” -Robert Kiyosaki

What is community and how does it play a role in social media?

What is community and how does it play a role in social media? This seems to be a fireball of a question in many organizations. When I was sitting in a community management session at SXSW with at least 30 community management professionals it was clear that this questions stirs up a lot of debate. In a recent discussion with someone agency side, I was amused that they seemed to be realizing that there are different competencies required to build a community versus forming and broadcasting a marketing message.  

All I can do is share my own perspective and interpretation.

Community management largely focuses on finding your advocates, evangelists, those that use your product, those that could use your product, those considering your product, those who have used your product, employees…anyone that has a connection to your brand can be considered a part of your community.  How you ‘manage’ community depends on your goals and what assets (people, software, budget) you have available. What is most important to you? Social media factors into community because the existence of social media has made it easier for communities to form – even without participation from the brand.

Where a lot of brands trip up, is that they use the terms community and social media marketing interchangeably. Social media marketing uses social media platforms as a channel to distribute marketing messages. Distributing social media marketing messages is not a means of growing or managing a community. However, using social media channels can help you engage and grow a community which can pave the way for gaining the trust of your community so that they will want to read, interact and amplify your social media marketing messages. If you have not built trust with your community in social networks, why would any form of community want to help you distribute your marketing messages?

This is where marketers trip up. They focus on building the volume of connections they have and here by volume, I mean they’re not too interested in who their connections are and how they pertain to their brand. They assume that by having a large number of connections – those connections will amplify their messages (meaning they’ll share them). But if I have no real affinity to your brand and we become connected on a social network, why would I share your marketing messages with MY community (my social media connections)? I wouldn’t unless I share the same frame of mind and think that sheer volume is the solution to growing a community. At the same time if someone becomes connected to you in a social network and you never interact with them, they may simply tire of your voice and disconnect.

And so there is a bit of a slippery slope because many companies use agencies to manage their communities and to develop their social media strategies and to execute their tactics. That might seem logical, but often this set-up lacks authenticity and your community knows that you’re connecting them with the simple goal of getting your marketing messages out. Further, many companies fail to develop a scalable means to continuing engaging and building relationships with people in their social media communities.

Building community requires building relationships. What amazes me is that some companies do not acknowledge people in their community, people talking about them regardless of sentiment. Here they lose the plot. They fail to realize the value of people having a voice and people having enough interest in their brand to say anything. Yet, by simply acknowledging your community means you have taken a step to building a relationship that further builds on any emotions people have about your brand.

Your community has needs and many of those needs if valued will provide you a lot of benefit. Those people talking about your in social channels care about you.

Examples:

Complainers: They need something that resembles what you have and they’re expressing discontent that your product isn’t quite meeting their requirements.

Advocates: They believe in your product and want you to keep succeeding.

Observers: They’re curious and they’re looking for a solution.

Evangelists: What a loving relationship, they believe in you and will tell the world about you and they will tell you when you don’t get it right. But don’t forget that passionate complainers have the propensity to become passionate in a more positive and possibly evangelistic way.

Journalists and bloggers: They’re always looking for their next story. Will they tell your story? They might tell the good and the bad but are you giving them what they need to tell your story?

Together community and social media create opportunities but they are not synonymous.

Goodbye Linkedin Answers!

Well this comes as no surprise (really): Linkedin Answers is closing down on January 31, 2013. On July 28, 2011 I posted this blog post – mostly out of frustration with the dire state of Linkedin Answers. This shut-down follows Events having closed down in November. It’s really no surprise. There are quite a few times I have monitored Answers by RSS feeds to respond to Questions I could. However, I frequently found that the quality of the Answers section was poor due to vendor-responses. For example, if someone asked a question about the best CRM software for a small business – they would likely find the answers were dominated by people selling CRM software. Sometimes the Answers were just plain dumb! Though I’m still disappointed that Answers is shutting down because sometimes there have been great Questions/Answers/Discussions like “What’s the basic difference between MVC and ASP.NET”.

linkedin-answers

(Which is BETTER? Answer? There is no Best.)

Where will people go now? Well despite being dominated by some ‘leaders’, KHE on MarketingProfs is a great resource for marketers. I’m sure those in technology will spend time on Quora and Stackoverflow. Also, I found this post about other websites where you can asks questions. If you try any, let me know!

Starbucks UK Facebook Photobooth Album Turns into a Tax Discussion

Social Media. It’s highly misunderstood by many…still. Yet, something that makes Social Media so amazing is how it shifted power and gave people a voice. Whether companies, politicians, people, organizations and so forth want to listen or not is entirely up to them. Nobody forces you to use social media. Well, perhaps your customers might. 

Last night we were watching Gordon Ramsay’s Kitchen Nightmares and talking about the Yelpers who had many negative things to say about this purveyor’s hamburgers. Yet the feedback was taken as vindictive criticism and further perceived as a ploy to send the restaurant out of business. I had to laugh. I once wrote a negative review about a business down the road and the owner’s husband found me on Linkedin and asked me to change my review because they believe it is negatively affecting their business (oh that’s another story). I understand the Yelpers…they’re people with an opinion and an outlet to share their views with other people…go there it’s great….don’t waste your money. Funny enough humans seem to enjoy peer-to-peer feedback. 

But what happens when you’re a big multi-national accused of not paying your fair share of taxes? Well Starbucks UK is sponsoring a skating rink in London. They have a nice café set up and have decked the seasonal halls with a fantastic photo booth. I was just looking on Starbucks UK Facebook page at the photo album and their good intentions have turned sour. Disgruntled tax payers have been posting their displeasure in the album’s comment section. 

Image

Ah the glory of Social Media for the people and the nightmare for any company’s PR department. How do you respond? Maybe Starbucks should whip out their smartphones and upload a photo of their tax payments along with justification documents. Of course they won’t. But people who don’t read the newspapers, or watch BBC, with social media even those not keenly interested in business news, those who just wanted to see if their photobooth pictures were in the Starbucks UK album will likely know that Starbucks UK is accused of not paying their taxes. And they just might be influenced by those who say they won’t do business with a multinational in the UK that isn’t paying their due part…

PingPong Facebook Page has the Best CTA ever!

Submit. That is the word that most companies want us to click when we fill out a form. Of course, subconsciously, who really wants to submit?  There are different definitions for the word submit but surely there are better choices?

I made this case a few years ago when I was a consultant at Oshyn, Inc. and we changed a form to say “Download” which was exactly what we wanted people to do.

Such buttons on forms present the final obstacle between the person supplying the information or not. This button is a Call to Action (CTA). Do you really want people to submit? But instead of asking someone to “DO” something why not make it a little more fun. Ping Pong (www.pingpongdimsum.com) used a Call to Action which begs for agreement from the person completing the form on the Ping Pong Facebook Page:

 Image

Yes! 

Linkedin Cannot Enforce an Element of User Agreement?

Recently, I was contacted by a birth relative who I wish to have absolutely no contact with. My response included “…I would appreciate it if you never contacted me again.”

I blocked this person’s email address. And foolishly thought that would be the end of that. Then this person sent me a contact request on Linkedin. So I emailed Linkedin and explained the situation asking if there was a way to prevent this person from sending further requests.

After all, Linkedin’s User Agreement states: 

Image

 

And yet, this was the response I received: 

Image

 

Am I really asking too much? I’ve been a member of Linkedin since I was invited in 2005…but now in light of recent events my only recourse was change my settings after being a member for 7 years, so that only someone with my email address can send me an invite? And since this person has my email address, this meant the only way to block them, was also to change my primary email address. (By the way, I have no idea how they obtained my email address in the first place). 

Image

 

In the Linkedin User Agreement it does state that they have the right to terminate someone’s profile for breaching the User Agreeement…

Image

 

What do you think? Do you think Linkedin should have some way to block individuals? 

 

PS – a big giant hug to Twitter for making it easy to block people. 

 

With LivingSocial Beauty is the Beast

I first discovered LivingSocial about a year ago. Every morning I receive a bunch of emails announcing current deals. LivingSocial is smart for putting each deal into a separate email – of course this way even if your eyes glaze over, you might still notice something that interests you.

But it seems Beauty is the Beast. I’ve used different types of services and had some great experiences except with beauty-related services.

Here are some examples:

I saw an offer in June for a Shellac manicure. I decided to buy a voucher since the business was not too far from my work. I have called many times since the day after I purchased my manicure and either a) nobody answered the phone, b) I was told there were no available appointments or c) I was told I would be put on a waiting list and called if there was space available. Is it any surprise that You Little Beauty has been all booked in December and will not accept the vouchers after the expiration date?

 

Now see how it says Three-Week manicure? I since learned that either You Little Beauty of LivingSocial misrepresented what was being sold. According to CND which makes Shellac…its a 14-Day manicure…

 

Its a manicure…but according to the voucher fine print (those lucky enough to get an appointment if they do exist) must arrive with their nails all clean and ready to go…

 

When I most recently called a week ago to try and make an appointment, as soon as I said I wanted a Shellac manicure I was quickly advised that they were booked up because the offer was expiring and they’d call me if there were any cancellations. The kicker is that I had not said anything yet about having a LivingSocial voucher…

 

I had also purchased a certificate for Kajree in Highgate for eyebrow threading and a head massage since I really am on the hunt for a place that does good threading in London. (Oh yes Los Angeles, you spoiled me!) I called the business several times, tried visiting in person and emailed and never receive an answer. From April to October, you can imagine this is pretty frustrating. As the expiration was approaching, I emailed LivingSocial and soon after I received an email from Kajree saying to call them. I still never managed to get in touch. It’s too bad because I really did want to find a place nearby that does threading. For the cost of £12 I gave up.

 

 

So why am I yammering on my blog lately about good service and bad service? Well because we’re in a time where people think alot more about value. I’m starting to feel like the money I’ve spent on un-redeemed LivingSocial vouchers will outweigh the savings. It seems to me I’m taking a gamble. This is terrible for LivingSocial because with all the money they surely spend on marketing, why would you want to be faced with these service failures? Well I did a small Google search and it seems like LivingSocial has some dissidents: http://www.sitejabber.com/reviews/www.livingsocial.com

 

So what do you think? Do you think that LivingSocial should refund certificates if the service offered is misrepresented like a Three-Week Shellac manicure?

What’s a fair solution for dealing with vendors who sell LivingSocial vouchers and then avoid redeeming them by being “fully-booked”?